Inside the Grand Chamber is an editorial series by Zouhaier Chihaoui on the highest formation of the European Court of Human Rights. A case reaches it by one of two routes: referral, which a party may request within three months of a Chamber judgment (Article 43 of the Convention), or relinquishment, where a Chamber relinquishes jurisdiction in favour of the Grand Chamber before it has delivered its judgment (Article 30).
The series opens with Article 43 itself: when should a case be referred to the Grand Chamber? It then turns to three cases: McCallum v. Italy, Lhermitte v. Belgium and Sylvie Vallée v. France.
How Just Rights Europe assesses and drafts requests for referral, and acts in proceedings before the Grand Chamber, is set out on our Grand Chamber page.
Article 43 of the Convention: how to identify a serious question that justifies a referral, with the examples of Bouyid, Lhermitte and Vallée.
McCallum v. Italy: extradition, diplomatic assurances and relinquishment of jurisdiction in favour of the Grand Chamber.
The reasons for the verdict: the jury rejected the conclusion of three court-appointed experts without having to say why, and the Grand Chamber found no violation by ten votes to seven.
The confiscation of jointly owned property and the protection of the spouse who was not convicted.
These notes are general information on Convention law; they do not constitute legal advice and do not create a lawyer-client relationship.
The three-month time limit for requesting referral runs from the date on which the judgment is delivered.